While Beethoven was labouring over the scorenof his third symphny, he
decided to name the symphony after Napoleon Bonaparte, then First
Consul of France. Where this idea came from is unclear. According to
his biographer and sometime secretary Anton Schindler, it had first
been suggested by Jean-Baptiste Bernadotte, the French ambassador to
Austria. But, according to Beethoven’s pupil Ferdinand Ries, the
idea was the composer’s own. As Ries explained, Beethoven had the
‘highest esteem’ for Napoleon and ‘compared him to the greatest
consuls of ancient Rome’. Whatever the case, Beethoven’s
enthusiasm for Bonaparte was unflinching. As soon as the score was
finished, in early 1804, he wrote the Italian words ‘Sinfonia
intitolata Bonaparte’ (‘Symphony entitled Bonaparte’) on the
cover and left the manuscript on a table so that all his friends
could see.
But Beethoven was in for a nasty surprise. Not long after putting the
final touches to his symphony, Ries came to him with news that, on 18
May 1804, Napoleon had declared himself Emperor of France. Beethoven
was furious. Flying into a rage, the composer shouted: ‘So he is no
more than a common mortal! Now he, too, will tread underfoot all the
rights of man [and] indulge only his ambition; now he will think
himself superior to all men [and] become a tyrant!’ Snatching up a
pen, Beethoven then strode over to the score and scribbled out the
title so violently that he tore through the paper. Thenceforth, the
work would be known simply as the Sinfonia Eroica (the ‘Heroic’
Symphony).